Last week, I was trying to explain to someone how widespread the pulp magazines were and how many stories (novels, novellas, novelettes, short stories, serial installments, etc.) had been produced during the pulp era. The gist of their question was: Haven’t all of those stories been reprinted?
At the time, I was reading the August 2026 mailing of the Pulp Era Amateur Press Society (PEAPS) and writing up my comments. Several of the PEAPS zines included overviews of stories that members had recently been reading.
I could talk about circulation figures in general, but couldn’t put my finger on actual numbers of individual titles or total number of issues, and was struggling to come up with a figure to express the volume of pulp stories that hadn’t been reprinted and were still out there to be read.
This week, while finally getting around to subscribing to PulpShelf (more on that shortly), I saw where the pulp-magazine collection tracker indexes around 680 titles and almost 42,500 issues. Those are pretty solid figures that would have helped me last week.
Let’s say a typical pulp magazine carried six to nine stories. Using the figures in PulpShelf’s database, that would mean there were roughly 255,000 to 382,500 stories published during the pulp era.
Of course, that’s just a ballpark estimate. Some magazines ran more stories, while others ran fewer. And some of the stories may have been reprints from dime novels or previous pulps.
So, have all the pulp stories been reprinted? Not even close. The Internet Archive’s Pulp Magazine Archive has scans of about 13,500 issues, roughly a third of what PulpShelf indexes, but not all of them are pulps. Add a generous 25,000 stories that have made it back into print, and you’re at about four in 10, at most. That still leaves well over half — something like 150,000 stories at the low end — that have never been reprinted or scanned.
If I read a story a day, I’d barely make scratch the surface. That’s why the story overviews in the PEAPS zines are worthwhile.
I may not get around to reading “The Bull Moose of the Bleachers” from Sport Story (April 22, 1925) or “Mystery Land” that was serialized in Argosy All-Story Weekly (1924), but I’m happy to read Alex Daoundakis‘s “Bull Moose” recap or Brian E. Brown‘s recounting of “Mystery Land.”
Now, back to PulpShelf. It’s an iOS app and website for cataloging your pulp collection. It was created by Matt Moring of Steeger Books and debuted last summer.
There are two tiers: a free one that lets you store your inventory/want list on your device, and an annual subscription that offers cloud synching and other features.
I’d intended to subscribe as soon as I returned home from PulpFest 2026, but got busy and only did so this week. I’m looking forward to setting up my collection. It will be nice to have it available in an app on my phone and not have to worry about carrying around a sheet of paper or looking for my Google spreadsheet.
If you’ve given PulpShelf a try, leave your impressions in the comments below. And if you’ve got a better estimate of how many pulp stories are out there, I’d like to hear that, too.



Add Comment